Possibly Pierre-André Jacquemin, his sale, Paris, 26 April 22 May 1773, lot 835: La naissance de Jesus-Christ idem. [à la plume & au bistre], or lot 836: LAdoration des Bergers; Probably Etienne-Maurice Falconet (1716-1791), sale of his heirs, Paris, Hôtel des Commissaires-Priseurs, 10 December 1866, lot 18, 37 or 42; With Thomas Agnew and Sons Ltd., London; Private Collection, England